There are, in fact, myriad criticisms that one might stage on the Federation and at Starfleet. For one, of their slavish devotion to Boldly Going The place No One Has Gone Earlier than, Starfleet can usually fail to comply with up on issues. On “Decrease Decks,” set a very good century after the occasions of the unique sequence, Starfleet was lastly seen following up on a civilization they liberated from a malevolent pc many years earlier than.
For an additional, Starfleet additionally represents a set of ethical and moral values that are not essentially shared by everybody within the galaxy, and even everybody within the group. If a pre-warp society is dying of a plague that the Enterprise can treatment, Starfleet ethics dictate that the individuals stay unaided, left to their very own gadgets in the case of their very own destiny. This, in fact, goes into compicated questions on the “Star Trek” Prime Directive, itself an anti-colonialist measure.
Starfleet values togetherness and cooperation and diplomacy, but in addition calls for from its officers a really particular code of conduct. And their code of conduct may be very conservative, requiring uniforms, a respect for a army rank, following orders, and belief within the system. Starfleet officers do not have alcohol on their ships, however booze-free synthehol. Even fraternization seems to be seen as unprofessional. Starfleet is, then, a contradiction. It is a company that encourages multiculturalism and welcomes outdoors viewpoints and clever interjections, however they require it below army auspices.
There are numerous different methods during which Starfleet could be criticized as nicely. However Boimler, in a second of anger, retains the extra optimistic points of Starfleet in thoughts. They do not need to flaunt their standing. They’re merely moved to do the correct factor.